When designing new construction, one should consider the surrounding “buildingscape”. When was this neighborhood built? What is the history? What style are the existing structures, how will the new design fit in or stand out? A good design blends function and form. A well thought out plan incorporates an updated look while complementing the existing environment.
Have you seen a contemporary glass and steel structure jutting out from a block of federal style brownstones? There is value in the new and interesting. There’s a way to introduce a high tech, modern edge into a classic space. The challenge is doing that while respecting the overall theme.
Have you seen the glass clad monstrosity that was imposed on the entrance of the Brooklyn Museum of Art, a handsome neo-classical building that now looks like there’s an adolescent 80’s style orthodontic night brace affixed to its front? Why would anyone do this? It’s insulting and out of place. This strange 2004 addition cost 55 million dollars and was inexplicably approved by New York Landmarks Preservation. A more well thought out design could have been utilized that preserved the integrity of the historic building. Consider the need, does the building need a larger entrance? Does it need a more user friendly access point? Does the plaza need updated hanging out spaces that encourage more museum goers? Consider the materials and the function. Consider the rear of the building and whether some modifications or additions could have been designed while honoring the formal plaza. Timeless classical design ages well, while chunky block concrete steps with rusty stains on them do not.
